Why Penalties Are Retaken in Football

Few moments confuse football fans more than seeing a penalty scored or saved—only for the referee to order it retaken. Whistles blow, players protest, and celebrations pause. This happens because penalty kicks are governed by strict positioning and movement rules that must be followed before and during the kick.

Understanding these rules explains why penalties sometimes have to be taken again.

You might also like

What Expected Goals (xG) Really Tells Us About Match Performance

13:42 ago

Encroachment Is the Most Common Reason

Encroachment occurs when players enter the penalty area too early.

This includes:

Related Article

West Ham United Complete Major January Signing of Taty Castellanos from Lazio

02:21 ago

• Attackers stepping inside before the kick
• Defenders entering early to clear rebounds
• Players moving off the arc too soon

If encroachment affects the outcome, the referee can order a retake.

Goalkeeper Movement Is Strictly Controlled

Goalkeepers must follow specific rules.

At the moment of the kick:

• At least one foot must be on or in line with the goal line
• The keeper cannot move forward early
• Lateral movement is allowed, forward movement is not

If the goalkeeper moves too early and gains an advantage, the penalty is retaken.

Why Some Saves Are Disallowed

A saved penalty can still be retaken.

This happens when:

• The goalkeeper leaves the line early
• The early movement clearly affects the save
• VAR confirms the infringement

The save may look impressive, but the rules still apply.

Why Scored Penalties Can Be Retaken

Even goals from penalties can be cancelled.

A retake may be ordered if:

• An attacking player encroaches and scores the rebound
• The penalty taker stops illegally during the run-up
• A double touch occurs

Illegal execution invalidates the goal.

Double Touch Violations

A penalty taker cannot touch the ball twice in succession.

This includes:

• The ball rebounding off the post back to the taker
• A slip that causes a second contact

If a double touch occurs, the goal is disallowed and play restarts accordingly.

Why VAR Gets Involved in Penalty Retakes

VAR closely monitors penalties.

It checks:

• Goalkeeper foot position
• Encroachment timing
• Illegal movement during the kick

Because penalties often decide matches, accuracy is prioritised.

Why Some Retakes Result in Yellow Cards

Goalkeepers can be cautioned for repeated offences.

Referees may:

• Warn first-time infringements
• Book repeat warnings
• Enforce discipline to prevent abuse

This is designed to maintain fairness.

Why Fans See More Retaken Penalties Now

Retaken penalties are more common because:

• VAR spots small infringements
• Rules are enforced more strictly
• Officials are less lenient on movement

In the past, many of these offences went unnoticed.

Why Referees Sometimes Ignore Encroachment

Not all encroachment leads to a retake.

Referees consider:

• Whether the infringement impacted play
• Who gained an advantage
• The outcome of the kick

Minor encroachment without impact may be ignored.

Psychological Impact of a Retaken Penalty

Retakes increase pressure dramatically.

For players:

• Confidence can drop
• Decision-making becomes harder
• Momentum may shift

A second attempt is often more difficult than the first.

Why Retakes Feel Unfair to Fans

Fans react strongly because:

• The moment feels decisive
• Celebrations are interrupted
• Rules seem overly strict

Emotion clashes with regulation in high-pressure moments.

When Penalties Are Rarely Retaken

Penalties usually stand when:

• All players remain outside the box
• The goalkeeper holds the line
• The kick is cleanly executed

Clear penalties are resolved quickly.

How This Helps You Read Live Matches

Understanding retakes helps fans:

• Anticipate VAR checks
• Understand referee whistles
• Stay calm during delays

It explains why penalties are rarely simple moments.

Final Thoughts

Penalties are retaken to protect fairness in one of football’s most decisive situations. Strict rules ensure that no player gains an unfair advantage—no matter how small the movement.

In modern football, precision matters as much as power.